If you’ve had Saltine toffee before, this recipe needs no explanation. Maybe you’re already nodding your head in agreement that this candy recipe, if any candy recipe ever, needed to be scaled down to prevent over-consumption. Personally, I can eat a whole pan of this stuff. I start chipping away at it shortly after breakfast, and before dinner, it’s gone.
I’ve heard it referred to as ‘crack toffee,’ a sentiment that I fully understand. It’s salty. It’s sweet. It’s chocolatey. What’s not to love?
Besides the addictive qualities of this toffee, another slippery slope is the ease with which you can whip it up. Got 10 minutes plus 20 minutes of chill time? You have crack. I mean, toffee. Even more so, I always seem to have the ingredients laying around. I love to roll chicken or pork chops in crushed Saltines before frying, so I’ve always got a few boxes on hand. And chocolate chips, hand-to-mouth, will always and forever be a favorite snack in this house. Add butter and brown sugar (even the hard stuff you forgot about in the back of your pantry), and you’re on your way!
You can top the toffee with anything you like–pecans, peanuts, heath bar bits, anything crunchy, really. I’m usually giving this as a holiday gift, so I err on the side of caution with nut allergies and just crush extra saltines on top. Plus, I like the even more salt.
If you’ve never had Saltine toffee before, I’m going to recommend that you never try it. It will wreck you. And your waist line. You should make this small batch recipe, divide it in two for holiday gifts, and delivery it immediately. Do not break off a tiny piece, do not lick the pan, do not pass go and collect $200. Treat it as poison.
Saltine Toffee
This sweet and salty treat is loved by everyone!
Ingredients
- 28 Saltine crackers (do not use the low-salt version)
- 5 tablespoons unsalted butter
- 1/2 cup dark brown sugar
- 1 cup semisweet chocolate chips
Instructions
- Preheat the oven to 350. Line a quarter sheet pan that measures 6 crackers by 4 crackers with aluminum foil.
- Line up 24 of the crackers on the pan. Even though the picture shows them salt sided up, place the crackers salted side down.
- In a small 1-quart saucepan, add the butter and brown sugar. Bring to a rolling boil--the entire pot will boil, not just the edges.
- Immediately pour the brown sugar mixture over the crackers. Try to pour it evenly, but know that it will spread some in the oven.
- Place the pan in the oven for 5 minutes. Check on it after 5 minutes to ensure that the toffee is bubbling. If so, remove it from the oven and scatter the chocolate chips on top.
- Let the chocolate chips set for 1 minute, then use an off-set spatula or knife to spread the melted mixture over the top of all of the crackers.
- Crush the remaining 4 crackers, and sprinkle it over the top of the chocolate.
- Refrigerate for 20 minutes to set.
- Break into pieces and serve.
Nutrition Information:
Yield:
16Serving Size:
1Amount Per Serving: Calories: 128Total Fat: 7gSaturated Fat: 4gTrans Fat: 0gUnsaturated Fat: 3gCholesterol: 10mgSodium: 53mgCarbohydrates: 16gFiber: 1gSugar: 12gProtein: 1g
Oh man, you can’t do this to me! I’d all but forgotten about this recipe. I second your recommendation for not trying this if you’ve never had it! I’m pretty sure I’ve eaten a whole plate of this stuff in one sitting.
Right, Maryea?! I almost forgot about this recipe, too! But my waist line wouldn’t let me ;) haha
Beautiful toffee! Looks like a perfect gift for the holidays too! :)
I love this stuff! It’s so easy to make and dang! It’s so addictive! :)
omg Christina this is genius!
OK, why have I never heard about this before? I am going home and making this!!! I seriously can’t wait for work to be over today lol. This is just brilliant, and I love the simplicity!
The stuff is the devil, and I will walk on the darkside for toffee!
I didn’t know about this until college and when I found out it was alllll over! I haven’t actually made it myself, but it looks like I need to : )
This stuff is so good! I had it for the first time last year, and I’m hooked forever!!
I want to make this but don’t want to make this because I know I would end up eating it all. I just wouldn’t be able to help myself. Ugh, the torture!
Definitely one of my favorite holiday snacks!! Love this!
Whoa…it must be sign! I was just thinking of this the past few days!
SPEAKING MY LANGUAGE RIGHT HEREE….. and I like it.
I have always wanted to make this. It’s time!
Oh I love this stuff! Salty, sweet, crunchy goodness!
Yes indeed. Definitely nodding my head in agreement with saltine toffee. Sweet & salty make the most harmonious combination.
:]
Had it. Love it. Now I need to make it!! Gorgeous photos!
I was about to say, this is a sign of pure evil. But it’s just so good. I can’t make it or else ADIOS any chance of a waistline again!
We’re toffee buddies today! But I am embarrassed to admit I’ve never had saltine toffee. Gonna need to fix that ASAP!
I LOVE this stuff, and can’t believe I have never made it. I had no idea it was so easy?! This is definitely happening soon. Thank you! (I think?)
I made toffee for the first time last year and I thought why haven’t I done this earlier. I feel like the saltine layer would be the perfect stabilizer so it isn’t too crumbly. Love this!
So, this is really, really popular here in the South, especially with pecans and no chocolate…ok so we are equally divided on the chocolate part! Haha! I have to tell you a funny story about this recipe and a lady that made this in an office I worked on years ago. So, it was Christmas and we were getting tons of candy and goodies in the office, and we’ll call her Flo, brought in this treat of toffee. Everyone fell in love with it, told her it was to die for, it was like crack, etc, etc…we all know how this stuff is…well, you know what happens when you bring in a treat or food that is exceptional, everyone wants the recipe. This is something, that for me is an honor, and I know it is really good, and I gladly share my recipes, that’s how they live on, get passed to the next generation. I make up pretty little recipe cards, with my name, or mine and who I orginally got it from, like a mini history, we have a big family cookbook that I’m putting together. Anyway, she would not share the recipe, she said she would, but the next day, instead of the recipe for the “crack” Toffee, she gave everyone a different recipe. When she came into my office and handed me the recipe, I looked at it and said this isn’t the recipe…she said”I know, that’s a family secret recipe. I can’t give it out”. I busted out laughing! Like it’s a state secret or something. So, I went home that night to the original cookbook it is printed in, copied the recipe and handed it out to everyone the next day…and put one on her desk. She looked at me shocked. I said “you aren’t the only one with secret family recipes, but my family shares!” It’s funny because I make certain treats every year, and give the recipes out when my family and friends ask, and even though they have them, whenever I’m coming…they still ask me to make them. It’s like it somehow tastes better if I make it
Haha! I love this story. I have a plea in my cookbook about how important it is to share recipes. No secrets in the kitchen :)
Christina, I do love this toffee. What do you think about using graham crackers and adding a small amount of salt? Do you think that would work?
I think it’s a fantastic idea! I’ll test it out soon. Let me know if you make it :)
Happy baking!
Christina
Graham crackers work just fine. My family is divided between Saltines and graham crackers so I usually make two sheet pans of the candy. I don’t have to eat too much of it; I just plan on making it when my boys are hanging out with friends. By the way, I know it as “Christmas Crack”.
I have actually never had saltine toffee! I must change this immediately!
(Un)fortunately, I hopped on the saltine-toffee crack train loooong ago and it has, in fact, ruined me. In the best way possible ;)
Yes, yes, yes.. a thousand times yes! My business advisor made these a couple years ago and I was just bllllooooown away by how truly incredible they were. I think I actually bought a box of saltines for the very purpose of recreating the straight-up crack but never did, so naturally the box is still in our pantry. It’s on, tonight!
I have seen this toffee for years and have never made it because I KNOW it’s danger. For sure. I has to be. I might make this when my family is here for Christmas. I can totally see my mom, sister-in-law, and myself killing a pan of this.
I need to make this right now, looks so delicious!!!
Totally guilty of being red-neckity and eating a whooooole lot of this stuff.
Love this sweet and salty combination!
must….listen. must…not….try….saltine toffee…
BUT IT LOOKS SO DANGED DELICIOUUUUS
I, too, call this crack. I like to top mine with crushed Starlight mints!
Oh great — now I feel compelled to go home and make some. You clearly are a BAAAAAD influence!!
I’ve been meaning to try making this for years! But with everything people say about it being crack toffee… I know I’d inhale the whole batch in less time than it took to make it. I have no self control around salty-sweet treats, especially when chocolate is involved! ;) Pinned!
Christina…this looks so good! I have never made saltine toffee. Definitely something I’m going to have to try!
I don’t know what rock I’ve been under, but this was the first time I’d ever had saltine toffee, and it is totally addicting! I am so glad you shared it on Facebook. I had to give away half the batch just so that I wouldn’t eat ALL of it. Even my dessert adverse hubby (more for me, right?) loved it. Super simple recipe that I will definitely be making over and over again.